Posted: 06/07/2010 01:00:00 AM MDTIn
addition to their entertainment value, dinner theaters cater to
special events — birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, etc. At
our local favorites, the food is usually passable, while the
musicals are the draw. To these venues, you can now add another
choice: The Broker's hearty menu and the outright silliness of
interactive murder mysteries.
"I Love Lucy . . . to Death" (which runs in
repertory with "The Return of Sherlock Holmes" on Saturday
nights), may not be "Oklahoma" or "The Sound of Music," but it
will get you up out of your chair — after that famous shrimp bowl
and a generous entree — into a line dance with Lucy, Ricky, Ethel
and Fred, as well as some very suspicious characters, and make you
wonder which one killed the wealthy philanthropist, Mrs. Pendalton
(Susan Rossman) who was going to help Ricky open his own club.
Rossman's upper-crust entitlement, with
faux fur and elevated American dialect, establishes the setting.
It helps that in entering the restaurant, we've walked past the
lobby of the most ornate, historic bank in Colorado, with a bar in
its stunning, grand old vault.
We're used to being served by actors who,
moments before, have thrilled us with a sweet rendition of "On the
Street Where You Live" or "Till There Was You," but it's a whole
different matter when Lucy (Giovanna Leah) and Ethel (Tanya K.
Obernyer) come to your table and try to involve you in their
shenanigans. We only wish there were more of this as the intrigue
progressed.
In an official Lucy wig, wide-eyed and as
effervescent as Lucille Ball, Leah's take on the famous "Vitameatavegamin
girl" skit from the TV series is as funny as it was when it first
aired in the '50s. Leah also scores with another old Lucy routine,
as a Camp Fire Girl reciting "Hiawatha."
If it's Ricky you crave, you'll sway to
Matthew Osmun's energetic, conga-drum-driven version of "Babalu"
as if you were watching the act from your table at the Tropicana
(sans palm trees). In fact, it's rumors about the Tropicana that
drive this plot.
While at the Manhattan Women's Club Charity
Dinner, Fred (Peter A. Stone) tells Ricky that he's learned from
the head waiter that the Tropicana is about to close. Fred and
Ricky cook up a scheme to raise money. Meanwhile, Lucy shows up,
with Ethel (Tanya K. Obernyer) in tow, to audition for the role of
the new Vitameatavegamin girl with a famous talent scout at the
charity event.
While Stone is not as curmudgeonly as we
remember William Frawley's Fred and Obernyer not as sardonic as
Vivian Vance's Ethel, they are just as good at insulting each
other. Dan Berman is Peter Lorre-sinister as Mrs. Pendalton's
executive assistant.